Carrie Underwood topped Bo Bice to win American Idol on May 28, 2005. Her debut single was "Inside Your Heaven," but "Jesus Take the Wheel" (released in October) would become her first No. 1 hit.

The Monday, April 28, episode of American Idol celebrated iconic moments from the show’s history, so it was only fitting that judge Carrie Underwood ‘s win was recognized. She won Season 4 in 2005 and ...