Meanwhile, Mr. Mackey gets fired from his job as school counselor at South Park Elementary because all counselors are being replaced by the Bible, and ends up joining ICE to “make his nut.” Noem shows up to lead his ICE raids and is portrayed as a constant puppy-shooter — a reference to her book in which she describes killing a 14-month-old dog named Cricket.

The second episode of the animated series' 27th season portrayed Noem - who has been dubbed "ICE Barbie" by detractors - as a puppy-shooting villain hellbent on rounding up Hispanics along with a team of beauticans who are constantly having to re-attach her melting face.